Paleo Foundation
  • Get Started
    • Apply Now
      • Paleo
      • Keto
      • Grain-Free
      • Paleo + Keto
      • Paleo + Grain-Free
      • Keto + Grain-Free
      • Paleo + Keto + Grain-Free
    • Standards
      • Certified Paleo Standards
      • Keto Certified Standards
      • Grain-Free Certified Standards
  • Certifications
    • Paleo Certification
    • Keto Certification
    • Grain-Free Certification
  • Certified Brands
  • Case Studies
  • Research Library
  • More
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • News
      • Keto Diet
      • Grain-Free
      • Paleo Diet
      • Microbiome
      • Case Studies
      • Announcements
      • Ingredients
      • Business
      • Espanol
Soylent, what?

Soylent, what?

February 7, 2014 9808 views

Recently while I was streaming through my Facebook feed while sitting in class, I ran across Soylent’s recently announced nutrition information.  I then decided to try to tackle Soylent and give it a breakdown of what I think it could be best used for.

What is Soylent?

For those of you who don’t know what Soylent is, it is a meal (or rather, food) replacement created by Rob Rhinehart.  The goal of this product is to provide food to those who don’t feel like—well, eating food. The idea of having people consume “daily recommendations” of nutrients without going through the hassle of cooking, cleaning, choosing, or – god forbid – chewing made waves across social media and news outlets.  Rhinehart launched a crowdsourcing campaign and raised over $2 million (20 times more than their goal of $100,000). Soylent is relatively cheap (just over $3 per meal, while Rhinehart wants to get it to less than $5 per day), and easy to make at home.  People have even come up with their own recipes for the drink.

So, onward with the nutrition information (it can be found here under the blog titled “Soylent 1.0 Final Nutrition” or in a PDF form given by the producers here). For the sake of this blog post, I will a very overview of both the micronutrients and macronutrients in different sections.

Macronutrients

The first thing on the list I notice, is the fat content. The fat in Soylent is a mere 5 grams (or 24 grams with the added oil packet), with 1 gram of saturated fat (3 with oil packet). For those of us who subscribe to diets high in dietary lipids, I think this strikes us hardest. The saturated fat content in the Soylent with the combined oil packet is comparable to a 3 ounce steak. A single avocado has more saturated and unsaturated fat in it than Soylent (and I’ve been known to eat more than one of those in a day), plus you can also make smoothies out of them. In addition, the fat in Soylent seems to come mainly from canola oil (56 grams vs the 6.4 grams from fish oil). Strike one for Soylent.

Next is the carbohydrate content. Soylent contains 84 grams of carbohydrates per serving (3.5 time more than that of fats with the added packet, and over twice that of protein).  The problem with this is that the carbohydrates seem to be sourced from Maltodextrin, a food additive made from starch (usually corn in America and wheat in Europe) that is rapidly absorbed by the body as glucose, along with oat flour.  I’m not so sure about you, but none of that sounds very Paleo to me.  It might also lead to a glucose crash (maybe that’s what was happening with this guy’s story). Strike two.

Finally, protein. From the ingriedients list, it seems as though rice protein is the main protein involved in Soylent. Rice protein (and oat flour) lacks the essential amino acid, lysine, which is involved in converting fats into energy, lowering cholesterol, increase calcium absorption, and building collagen, a major connective tissue found throughout the body. Oat flour is just as bad with lysine, so I wouldn’t expect consumers of Soylent to get much of this amino acid in their diet. I think people would be much better off simply eating meat. Strike three.

Micronutrients

Though the micronutrient content doesn’t seem so awful, as does the macronutrient content, I still have some worries for Soylent.  I’m skeptical about the bio-availability of many of the nutrients, especially because much of the drink is made from rice protein and oat flour.  It raises the question “are we actually digesting all of the nutrients that are supposed to be in Soylent?” That, I don’t know. It seems like the drink would have a large amount of phytates, lectins, and other antinutrients that could harm your chances of absorbing vitamins and minerals.  Plus, with the fat content, I wouldn’t be surprised if much of the fat-soluble vitamins (A,D,E, and K) go to waste since the vitamins need to dissolve in fat in order to pass through the intestine.

Ok, so it may not be so good for you, but are there any positives?

Absolutely!

The idea that a days worth of Soylent could be sold for $5 is amazing! In a time where Americans are starting to learn to thrive with their health, millions around the world are still struggling to survive.  Many are unable to get even the minimum amount of nutrients to survive, and however bad Soylent may be for us to thrive on, it could put a huge dent in the numbers of those struggling to survive.  Plus, you also have to remember that the $5 mark still gives Rhinehart some profit.  Imagine what it could do if it were funded from donations or non-profit sectors. I think, if given the right circumstances, that Soylent could challenge the great strides that were created by Plumpy’nut (which costs about $60 for two months worth). It could be a challenge to hunger everywhere.

Comments

comments

Previous article Michael Pollan Paleo Interview
Next article Coconut Pudding with Prunes
Stephen Decker

Stephen Decker

I am a student from Texas studying kinesiology and health science. On the side I like to venture into public policy and research the consequences of legislation, especially those concerning health. I began my journey in Paleo in 2011, after I began researching the links of chronic disease and diet. I then began learning more and more about the Paleo Diet, and became very active in my local community in spreading the ideas behind Paleo.

Similar posts from related categories

Hope for The American Diet

Hope for The American Diet

Navigating Junk Food, Snacks, and Child Food Sensitivities in School

Navigating Junk Food, Snacks, and Child Food Sensitivities in School

The Business of Medicine: Doctors, Diet, and Common Sense

The Business of Medicine: Doctors, Diet, and Common Sense

<span class="hot">Hot <i class="fa fa-bolt"></i></span> How to tell if you suffer from Dietary Dogmatic Asshole Complex (DDAC)

Hot How to tell if you suffer from Dietary Dogmatic Asshole Complex (DDAC)

Drunken Monkey History of Man: NSFW Proof Alcohol Is Paleo

Drunken Monkey History of Man: NSFW Proof Alcohol Is Paleo

Is Agave Nectar Paleo?

Is Agave Nectar Paleo?

Nom Nom Paleo Disappointment

Nom Nom Paleo Disappointment

Parents, Get It Together

Parents, Get It Together

Comments

  • ian ian June 13, 10:55

    I don't understand. Before stating "strike two", you link to a guy who took soylent for two weeks and concluded with the following... "I was happy. Life was starting to feel simple. I felt… lighter… inside. Which is a hard thing to objectively measure, but that was the case. And by the final day, to my surprise, I found myself wishing I had two more weeks’ of Soylent left." Which part was strike two?

    Reply
Post Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

Latests News

Keto Claims in the European Union: Rules and Regulations on Products

Keto Claims in the European Union: Rules and Regulations on Products

April 14, 2022
Purely Elizabeth’s Grain-Free Pancakes: an Innovative Strategy

Purely Elizabeth’s Grain-Free Pancakes: an Innovative Strategy

The Complex Associations between Diet and the Environment 

The Complex Associations between Diet and the Environment 

February 11, 2022
Kevin’s Natural Foods: Market Analysis and Innovation to Create a Niche

Kevin’s Natural Foods: Market Analysis and Innovation to Create a Niche

HPAEC PAD for Net Carbohydrate Claims on Keto Product Packaging

December 7, 2021
Keto Market Growth and Trends Forecasts 2021

Keto Market Growth and Trends Forecasts 2021

14
Apr 10:16

Keto Claims in the European Union: Rules and Regulations on Products

18
Feb 10:00

Purely Elizabeth’s Grain-Free Pancakes: an Innovative Strategy

11
Feb 01:54

The Complex Associations between Diet and the Environment 

13
Jan 10:10

Kevin’s Natural Foods: Market Analysis and Innovation to Create a Niche

07
Dec 06:12

HPAEC PAD for Net Carbohydrate Claims on Keto Product Packaging

03
Dec 09:38

Keto Market Growth and Trends Forecasts 2021

  1. Announcements
  2. Business
  3. Case Studies
  4. Case Study
  5. Commentary
  6. Discussion
  7. Espanol
  8. Fitness
  9. Grain-Free
  10. Health
  11. Ingredients
  12. Interviews
  13. Keto Diet
  14. Market
  1. Methodology
  2. Microbiome
  3. Misc.
  4. News
  5. Opinion
  6. Other
  7. Paleo Diet
  8. Philosophy
  9. Products
  10. Recipes
  11. Research
  12. Sustainability
  13. Thanksgiving

Popular Posts

5 Consejos para el Equilibrio Hormonal Femenino

5 Consejos para el Equilibrio Hormonal Femenino

August 14, 2018
What’s Your Paleo Poop Telling you?

What’s Your Paleo Poop Telling you?

August 11, 2018
Ceylon vs Cassia : 9 Important Things You Need to Know about Cinnamon

Ceylon vs Cassia : 9 Important Things You Need to Know about Cinnamon

November 9, 2016
19 Gluten Cross-Reactive Foods Busted Myth

19 Gluten Cross-Reactive Foods Busted Myth

Best Ever Paleo Thanksgiving Stuffing Recipe

Best Ever Paleo Thanksgiving Stuffing Recipe

October 11, 2016
alcohol 4
breakfast 15
Business 2
case study 30
Certification 2
community 5
desserts 29
Diet 8
fall 30
Grain Free Diet 1
health 36
holiday season 10
Interviews 5
keto certification 1
keto vegan 1
main 25
Opinion 4
PCR 2
Philosophy 5
Popular 12
PRR 1
sides 16
Sustainability 6
trade news 1
why get certified 10
© 2022 Copyright Paleo Foundation. All Rights reserved.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Report an Infringement
Close Window

Loading, Please Wait!

This may take a second or two. Loading, Please Wait!